Sequence-of-returns risk: why the first years of retirement matter most

Two retirees can earn the same average return and still end up with very different balances, because withdrawals make the order of good and bad years matter; here is how it works, with invented numbers.

A winding path through a forest in early morning light.

Two people retire the same year with the same savings. Over the next five years their portfolios earn exactly the same returns, just in a different order, and they withdraw the same dollars. One ends up with about $123,000 more than the other. This guide uses invented numbers to show why, and what it means for a withdrawal plan.

This is general education, not individual financial, investment or tax advice. Every return below is an assumption chosen to make a point, not a forecast, and past performance does not guarantee future results.

The puzzle: same average, different results

Sequence-of-returns risk is the risk that the timing of market gains and losses, not just their average, decides how long money lasts once you are withdrawing from it. While you are saving, the order of returns barely matters to the final total. Once you are taking money out, it matters a great deal.

The reason is simple arithmetic. A loss early in retirement hits a portfolio that is about to be drawn down further. The dollars you withdraw come out of a smaller base, so fewer dollars are left to recover when markets turn.

An invented example, step by step

Everything here is hypothetical. Two retirees, Retiree A and Retiree B, each start with $1,000,000. Each withdraws $50,000 at the start of every year, a fixed amount with no inflation adjustment, to keep the arithmetic visible. The remaining balance then earns that year’s return.

Both portfolios see the same five annual returns, in opposite order:

The simple average of those five returns is 4.0% for both. The compound return is also identical for both, about 2.6% a year, because multiplying the same five growth factors gives the same product in any order.

Here is Retiree A, year by year. Each line is (balance minus $50,000) times (1 plus the return):

And Retiree B:

After five years, Retiree A has about $796,981 and Retiree B about $920,435, a gap of roughly $123,000. Same savings, same withdrawals, same returns.

Two paths of stepping stones crossing a stream, one higher and one lower.

Why the order only matters once you withdraw

Run the same example with no withdrawals and the two retirees finish identically. In both cases, $1,000,000 grows by the same product of five growth factors, 1.1385, to $1,138,500. Reordering multiplication changes nothing.

Withdrawals break that symmetry. Retiree A’s second withdrawal of $50,000 is taken from a balance of $760,000, which is 6.6% of the portfolio (50,000 ÷ 760,000). Retiree B’s second withdrawal is taken from $1,187,500, which is 4.2%. Retiree A is selling more of a depressed portfolio to fund the same lifestyle, so when markets recover there are fewer shares left to benefit.

Five years is short, and the effect compounds over a longer retirement. A bad run in the first years can leave a portfolio too small to be rescued by later good years, while the same bad run in a late year hits a balance that has already grown.

What this has to do with the 4% rule

The 4% rule is a response to this risk. The research behind the rule did not rest on average returns. As the guide to the 4% rule describes, Bengen’s 1994 study used actual year-by-year US returns and inflation, imagining a retiree starting in each year from 1926 onward, because a bad run early in retirement can do lasting damage. That guide covers what the studies tested and assumed. The example above shows the same mechanism in miniature: a single average return is a poor way to judge a withdrawal plan.

For readers using a target based on a multiple of annual spending, a lower assumed withdrawal rate means a larger target, which is one way people allow for a bad start. Someone retiring much earlier than the traditional age also faces a longer stretch in which a poor sequence can occur.

What official guidance says

FINRA, the securities industry’s self-regulator, publishes retirement-income guidance that touches on the same problem. It says expert opinion on withdrawal rates tends to cluster between 3 and 5 percent, while stressing that no single percentage fits everyone. It says most planning specialists suggest beginning withdrawals at a cautious level, that experts advise against overspending in the first few years, and that people should be ready to reduce discretionary spending after a losing year. It also suggests building inflation into yearly withdrawals (FINRA, Managing Your Retirement Portfolio, checked November 18, 2026).

That is guidance, not a rule that fits everyone. A starting withdrawal in that range is not a guarantee, and the page does not name a rate for any particular person.

Ways people plan around the risk

None of these removes the risk, and each has trade-offs. They are described here as common approaches, not recommendations.

A lower starting withdrawal. This leaves more room for a bad start, at the cost of a bigger savings target.

Spending flexibility. Reducing discretionary spending after a losing year, which FINRA mentions, is one form. Flexible spending trades a steady budget for less pressure on the portfolio in downturns.

Income from other sources early on. Part-time earnings in the first years mean smaller withdrawals when balances may be depressed. Pensions and Social Security later in retirement reduce how much the portfolio has to carry; the Social Security Administration offers online benefit calculators (SSA, Benefit Calculators, checked November 18, 2026). Our guide to Social Security claiming ages shows how the choice of age changes income over time.

A cash or bond buffer. Some people hold a reserve to draw on in a downturn so they are not selling stocks at low prices. This reduces the volatility of what is withdrawn but leaves less invested for growth, and how much to hold would depend on personal circumstances.

A larger starting balance. Savings built through a high savings rate can also add a cushion beyond the minimum target.

What the example leaves out

The example is deliberately simple. It uses five years, round percentages, a fixed withdrawal at the start of each year and no inflation, fees or taxes. Real portfolios mix several asset types, and real withdrawals usually rise with prices. Rebalancing, fund costs and the tax treatment of each account would all change the numbers. A tax professional can confirm how withdrawals from different accounts are taxed in your situation.

Common questions

What is sequence-of-returns risk? It is the risk that the order of returns, especially poor ones early in retirement, reduces how long a portfolio lasts when money is being withdrawn, even if the average return is unchanged.

Does the order of returns matter while I am still saving? Not for the final total when you make no deposits or withdrawals in between: the same returns multiply to the same result in any order. It matters most when regular withdrawals are taken out.

Is a 4% withdrawal rate safe? No rate is guaranteed. The 4% figure comes from historical studies with specific assumptions, and FINRA says expert opinion on withdrawal rates tends to cluster between 3 and 5 percent, with no single percentage that fits everyone.

Can I avoid sequence risk completely? No approach removes it. Lower withdrawals, flexible spending, other income and cash buffers can reduce its effect, each with costs.

Sources checked November 18, 2026: FINRA, Managing Your Retirement Portfolio; SSA, Benefit Calculators.