Paying Down Debt: List It, Order It and Choose a Method
How to list what you owe, why minimum payments come first, and how the highest-rate-first and smallest-balance-first methods compare, with one worked example.

When you owe on several accounts, the question is rarely whether to pay. It’s where the next spare dollar goes. There are two well-known ways to decide, and they trade off different things: one usually costs less in interest, the other usually gives an earlier win.
This guide explains how to lay out what you owe, how the two methods work, and what the federal consumer agencies say about getting help. It describes trade-offs, not which method to pick, and the worked example uses invented figures.
List every balance, rate and minimum
A plan starts with one list. For each debt, write down four things from the latest statement:
- Who you owe.
- The balance.
- The interest rate (the APR).
- The minimum monthly payment and its due date.
Then add up the minimums. That total is the fixed cost of your debts each month. Anything you can pay beyond it is your extra payment, and the whole question of method is about where that extra goes.
The CFPB offers a debt worksheet and a bill calendar for this step in its guide to reducing debt (CFPB, checked November 15, 2026). To find the extra in the first place, a spending review and a budget method are the usual starting points.
Why the minimums come first
Both methods start the same way: every account gets at least its minimum payment, every month. The CFPB spells that step out in its description of the smallest-balance method, and highest-rate-first is normally run the same way.
The reason is that a missed minimum costs more than interest. The CFPB notes that stopping payments on a card can bring late fees, penalty interest and collection activity (CFPB, checked November 15, 2026). The exact fees and rates are set out in each account’s own agreement.
The minimum is a floor, not a plan. The CFPB says that with only the minimum payment, a credit card could take years to pay off. Card statements are required to show how long payoff would take at the minimum with no new charges, and the monthly amount that would clear the balance in 36 months (CFPB, checked November 15, 2026).
Two ways to order the extra payment
The CFPB describes two strategies.
Highest interest rate first (often called the “avalanche”). The extra payment goes to the debt with the highest rate. When that debt is gone, its whole payment moves to the next-highest rate. The CFPB’s summary: this targets the debt that is costing the most, which may save money over time, but progress may feel slow.
Smallest balance first (often called the “snowball”). The extra payment goes to the smallest balance, whatever its rate. When that debt is gone, its whole payment rolls on to the next-smallest. The CFPB’s summary: results show up faster, but you may pay more over time.
Neither is the official method. The CFPB presents both and leaves the choice to the reader’s goals.

A worked example with invented figures
These three debts are hypothetical, chosen to keep the arithmetic easy to follow.
| Debt | Balance | APR | Minimum |
|---|---|---|---|
| Store card | $600 | 24% | $25 |
| Credit card | $3,000 | 28% | $90 |
| Personal loan | $5,000 | 10% | $160 |
| Total | $8,600 | $275 |
Assumptions: $500 a month goes to debt in total, so the extra payment is $500 − $275 = $225. Interest is added once a month at one-twelfth of the APR. The minimums stay fixed, no new charges are made, there are no fees, and when a debt is cleared its payment rolls to the next one.
Month 1 looks like this. Interest is $12 on the store card ($600 × 24% ÷ 12), $70 on the credit card ($3,000 × 28% ÷ 12) and $41.67 on the loan ($5,000 × 10% ÷ 12). Under highest-rate-first, the extra $225 goes to the credit card, which ends the month at $3,000 + $70 − $90 − $225 = $2,755. Under smallest-balance-first, it goes to the store card, which ends the month at $600 + $12 − $25 − $225 = $362.
Carrying that forward month by month gives:
| Highest rate first | Smallest balance first | |
|---|---|---|
| First debt cleared | Credit card, month 11 | Store card, month 3 |
| All debts cleared | Month 20 | Month 20 |
| Total interest paid | About $1,119 | About $1,141 |
In this example, highest-rate-first saves about $21 in interest. Smallest-balance-first clears its first account eight months sooner. Both finish in the same month.
The gap here is small because the smallest debt also carries a high rate. With other figures the result changes: a large balance at a very high rate makes the interest saving bigger. That’s why this is an illustration and not a forecast. Real card minimums also tend to change with the balance, which this simple model leaves out.
What each method trades off
| Highest rate first | Smallest balance first | |
|---|---|---|
| Total interest | Usually lower | Usually higher |
| First account closed out | Can take a while | Usually sooner |
| Tends to appeal to someone who | Is motivated by the total cost | Is motivated by visible progress |
Some people mix them: clear one very small balance for simplicity, then switch to highest rate first. Either way, the arithmetic assumes no new charges are being added to the same accounts.
Where an emergency fund fits
Paying down debt and saving can pull against each other. The CFPB points out that without savings, an unexpected bill often ends up on a credit card or loan, where interest and fees make it larger than the original cost, and that even a small amount set aside provides some security (CFPB, checked November 15, 2026).
That’s why one common approach is to hold a small starter cushion while paying debt, so that a car repair is less likely to undo months of progress, and to build the full fund afterwards. It is one approach, not a rule: whether to follow it, and how big “small” is, depends on your own costs and risks, and the CFPB doesn’t set a figure. The emergency fund guide walks through the sizing, and the irregular expenses guide covers the bills that are predictable but not monthly.
Where to get help
If the minimums themselves are out of reach, a different kind of help applies.
Your creditors. The FTC suggests contacting creditors early, before a debt collector is involved, to explain the situation and ask about a payment plan you can manage (FTC, checked November 15, 2026).
Credit counseling. The CFPB describes credit counseling organizations as usually nonprofit, offering free or low-cost advice on money, debts and budgeting (CFPB, checked November 15, 2026). Some arrange a debt management plan: one monthly payment to the organization, which pays the creditors. The CFPB’s checklist for choosing a counselor includes getting fees quoted in writing, looking for a range of services and not only a debt management plan, and confirming with your creditors that they have accepted a plan before sending payments.
Debt settlement companies are different. They are businesses that say they can negotiate with creditors to reduce what you owe. The CFPB’s warnings include expensive fees, advice to stop paying your bills (which brings late fees and penalty interest), creditors that may refuse to deal with the company or may sue, damage to credit scores, and possible income tax on forgiven debt. In its words, debt settlement “may well leave you deeper in debt than you were when you started.” The FTC adds that a debt settlement company can’t collect its fees before it settles your debt.
If rewards are part of the reason you keep using a card that carries a balance, Points Professor’s guide to credit card interest versus rewards shows how the interest compares with what the card earns.
Common questions
Which debt gets paid first? Under both methods every debt gets its minimum. The extra goes to the highest rate (avalanche) or the smallest balance (snowball). The first usually costs less in interest; the second usually closes an account sooner.
Is the avalanche method cheaper than the snowball? In total interest, usually, given the same monthly amount. How much cheaper depends on the balances and rates; in the invented example above it was about $21.
Is it possible to save and pay down debt at the same time? Many people hold a small cushion while paying debt, because an emergency with no savings tends to create new debt. The split depends on your own situation.
What is a debt management plan? An arrangement made through a credit counseling organization: you make one monthly payment to it, and it pays your creditors. The FTC notes these plans aren’t for debts secured by a house or car.
This guide is general education, not individual financial advice.
Sources checked November 15, 2026: CFPB, how to reduce your debt, CFPB, the payoff box on a credit card statement, CFPB, guide to building an emergency fund, CFPB, what is credit counseling, CFPB, debt settlement and debt relief services and FTC, how to get out of debt. The worked example is our own calculation from the assumptions stated.